WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BALLOONFISH AND PORCUPINEFISH? They’re both unobtrusive, usually little guys with an ability to inflate into spiny basketball-shapes when disturbed. It’s a defensive response to threats. And, divers are often confused as to which is which.
First of all, when you see picture of them, they’re often inflated like stuffed pincushions.
But the truth is that recreational divers who are minding their manners are unlikely to see them in a puffed-up state (Note to wiseguys seeking to initiate inflation: leave them alone).
MONA LISA SMILES
With their bulky shapes in uninflated modes, they’ve have been described as “footballs with a tail.” Big-eyed and gentle, permanently affixed with Mona Lisa smiles, they swim languidly – although as good bottom feeders, they’re agile at hovering. In fact, they’re often observed resting on the bottom.
SIMILAR TRAITS, DIFFERENT SPECIES
They’re both in Family Diodidentae or, in street jargon, the “Porcupinefish Family,” and balloonfish are sometimes just identified as “spiny porcupinefish.”
But balloonfish and porcupinefish are different species, and the ones that have the more obvious spines are the balloons, not the porcupines. Spines increase their deterrence to predators (in 2017, a lemon shark in the Maldives made the news by suffocating to death when a porcupine got stuck in its gullet; unfortunately, it didn’t end well for the porcupine, either).
BALLOONFISH, PORCUPINEFISH – AND PUFFERFISHES
It should be noted that while porcupines and balloons are often referred to as “puffers,” there’s a separate group (Tetraodontidae) that actually is the “Pufferfish Family,” fishes that can also inflate themselves but lack spines, like the sharpnose puffer and goldface tobies in the Caribbean and numerous species of tobies in the Indian-Pacific basin .They’re fishes for a different discussion.
PORCUPINE AND BALLOONFISH CHARACTERISTICS
- Inflatability: Porcupinefishes and balloonfishes can inflate themselves because they have elastic stomachs they can fill with water, swelling their bodies as much as three times their uninflated size. This capability comes with an adaptation: their stomachs have lost their digestive function, which takes place in their lower intestines.
- The action of inflation causes porcupines’ and balloons’ spines to become erect.
- Feeding: Because their foods of choice include hard-shelled creatures like snails, hermit crabs and sea urchins, they have fused teeth and powerful jaws that can crack shells. Reportedly, divers who have tried to handle them (don’t do this!) have found out that their powerful jaws are strong enough to break fingers.
- Porcupinefish and balloonfish are described as nocturnal but it’s not unusual to see them during the daytime. They’re often described as solitary fishes that hang out in holes or under ledges, but it’s also not unusual to see them in the open. Their large eyes, which often appear to be emerald blue, are a bonus for nighttime foragers.
- Toxicity: No discussion of balloonfish and porcupinefish would be complete without talking about the risks of poisoning – potentially fatal – caused by tetrodotoxin toxins found in the flesh of some puffers. Naturally, the risk makes gourmands in Japan and other societies consider puffers to be a delicacy called fugu. This is different from ciguatera poisoning, resulting from an accumulation of dinoflagellates that is sometimes found in many species of fishes.
PRINCIPAL SOURCES: Reef Fish Identification, Galapagos & Florida, Caribbean, Bahamas, Paul Humann, Ned DeLoach; Reef Fish Identification, Tropical Pacific, Gerald Allen, Roger Steene, Paul Humann, Ned DeLoach; Marine Life, Caribbean, Bahamas, Florida, Marty Snyderman & Clay Wiseman; “Porcupinefish,” Florida Museum of Natural History; “Balloonfish,” Aquarium of the Pacific; “Diodon holocanthus Blotched porcupine (Also Spiny balloonfish,” University of Michigan Animal Diversity Web; “Hard to Swallow: Shark Suffocates on Porcupine Fish,” Mindy Weisberger, Live Science.